Home Viral Social Buzz 2

The Proposal That Never Was: Did Jeremy Really Say He Would Propose To Susie On Bachelor In Paradise?

• minute read
Contents

The question of whether Jeremy Simon promised to propose to Susie Evans is one of the most explosive and contentious pieces of drama to ever emerge from the beaches of Bachelor in Paradise. This controversy, which unfolded during Season 10, centered on a shocking private conversation that threatened to derail Jeremy's relationship with Bailey Taylor Brown and left fans reeling from the audacity of the revelation.

As of December 22, 2025, the answer is a resounding 'Yes,' Jeremy Simon did, in fact, tell a fellow contestant that he would propose to Susie Evans if she returned to the show. This bombshell confession, which was later denied by Jeremy, led to a massive confrontation on the beach, but the current relationship status of all three individuals proves that reality TV drama rarely dictates real-life outcomes.

The Central Figures: A Biographical Snapshot

The infamous proposal rumor involves three key players from the Bachelor Nation franchise: Jeremy Simon, Susie Evans, and Bailey Taylor Brown. Understanding their background is essential to grasping the intensity of the *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10 drama.

Susie Evans

  • Born: Susan Christine Evans, August 19, 1993
  • Age: 32 (as of December 2025)
  • Hometown: Poquoson, Virginia
  • Occupation: Wedding Videographer, TV Host, and Program Manager.
  • Franchise History: Winner of *The Bachelor* Season 26 (with Clayton Echard) and contestant on *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10.
  • Current Relationship Status (Dec 2025): Single. She was in a relationship with Justin Glaze (2023-2024) after a brief connection with him on *Paradise*.

Jeremy Simon

  • Hometown: Fairfield, Connecticut
  • Occupation: Engineer (Civil Engineering and Mathematics degree from the University of Connecticut).
  • Franchise History: Contestant on *The Bachelorette* (Jenn Tran's season) and *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10.
  • Key Traits: Described as spontaneous and loyal, with a love for travel.

Bailey Taylor Brown

  • Age: 28
  • Hometown: Atlanta, Georgia
  • Occupation: Marketing Executive/Social Media Manager.
  • Franchise History: Contestant on *The Bachelor* (Grant's season) and *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10.

The Shocking Confession: "I Would Propose to Susie"

The drama that captivated Bachelor Nation began when Susie Evans arrived on the beach in *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10. Despite Jeremy Simon having already formed a strong initial connection and coupling up with Bailey Taylor Brown, he accepted a date with Susie.

Following the date, Jeremy gave his rose to Bailey, a decision he quickly seemed to regret. The situation escalated dramatically when Jeremy confided in fellow contestant Brian Autz, admitting he couldn't stop thinking about Susie.

The bombshell statement, which was reportedly caught on a hot mic or revealed in a private conversation, was: "If she came back, I would give Susie the rose, and I'll just, like, propose to her." Other reports corroborated this, with Brian telling Bailey that Jeremy said he'd "propose to Susie on the spot" if she returned. A clip even showed Jeremy saying he'd propose to Susie "in a minute."

This confession was particularly shocking because Jeremy was actively pursuing a relationship with Bailey, who was shown gushing about being ready for the next step with him just as the proposal rumor surfaced. The revelation created a massive ethical dilemma for Brian, who ultimately felt compelled to tell Bailey, leading to a huge rift between the couples.

The situation was further complicated by Jeremy’s response. While multiple sources and clips confirmed the statement, Jeremy later denied ever saying that he'd propose to Susie if she came back to the show. This denial, despite the evidence, only intensified the drama and led to criticism from other cast members, including Andrew Spencer, who said Jeremy "looks really bad."

The Aftermath: Where Jeremy, Susie, and Bailey Stand Now in December 2025

The proposal drama was a major turning point in *Bachelor in Paradise* Season 10, but the current reality for the three entangled parties is arguably more surprising than the initial scandal.

Jeremy Simon and Bailey Taylor Brown: Still Together and Taking the Next Step

Despite the massive hurdle of the "Susie proposal" confession, Jeremy and Bailey managed to work through the controversy. Bailey ultimately forgave Jeremy, and they decided to continue their relationship, leaving the beach as a couple.

As of late 2025, Jeremy and Bailey are still very much an item. Reports from August and September 2025 confirm that the *Bachelor in Paradise* couple is committed and has decided to take the next step in their relationship, navigating a long-distance arrangement between Jeremy in New York and Bailey in Los Angeles/Nashville. Their ability to survive the most dramatic rumor of the season speaks volumes about the strength of their post-show connection.

Susie Evans: Single and Focused on the Future

Susie Evans did not return to the beach after her date with Jeremy, effectively ending the possibility of the on-the-spot proposal he mentioned. After *Paradise*, Susie formed a relationship with fellow contestant Justin Glaze, but that relationship ended in 2024.

As of December 2025, Susie is single. She has been open about her relationship status being "complicated" at various points, but she remains a prominent figure in Bachelor Nation, focused on her career and personal life.

The Proposal That Never Was

The short answer to the central question—did Jeremy Simon say he would propose to Susie Evans—is definitively yes, according to multiple sources and clips from the show. However, the proposal itself never materialized because Susie did not return to the beach. The true irony is that the man who was ready to propose to one woman "on the spot" ultimately ended up in a long-term, committed relationship with the woman he was dating at the time of the confession, proving that even the most scandalous reality TV moments can be overcome by a real-world connection.

The Proposal That Never Was: Did Jeremy Really Say He Would Propose to Susie on Bachelor in Paradise?
did jeremy say he would propose to susie
did jeremy say he would propose to susie

Detail Author:

  • Name : Khalid Roberts
  • Username : kunde.devin
  • Email : marquardt.stanton@gmail.com
  • Birthdate : 1995-06-04
  • Address : 2165 Schneider Row West Sidhaven, KS 36086-5044
  • Phone : +1-503-239-6078
  • Company : Ritchie, Green and Smith
  • Job : Financial Manager
  • Bio : Voluptatibus voluptatem excepturi adipisci provident adipisci at. Eos nobis quis est in laudantium. Esse et laborum est itaque eligendi aut est. Et praesentium quasi quaerat.

Socials

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/samir3315
  • username : samir3315
  • bio : Distinctio et rerum illo expedita asperiores sint. Error consequatur non doloribus laboriosam facilis. Necessitatibus similique natus velit cum.
  • followers : 2185
  • following : 2945

linkedin:

Random Posts