Home Viral Celebrity Scoop 1

7 Heavenly Secrets Behind AJ's Heavenly Pizza Findlay Ohio's Unstoppable Success In 2025

• minute read
Contents

For over four decades, the name "AJ's Heavenly Pizza" has been synonymous with quality, homemade pizza in Northwest Ohio, a tradition that continues to thrive today under the banner of Heavenly Pizza in Findlay, Ohio. As of late 2025, this beloved local institution is not just serving up fresh dough and proprietary sauces; it’s upholding a legacy of community engagement and exceptional customer service that sets it apart from national chains. This article dives deep into the history, the menu must-haves, and the inspiring philosophy that makes the Findlay location a true culinary cornerstone.

The journey from a small-town start to a regional favorite is a testament to consistency and dedication. Located at 1132 Tiffin Ave., at the busy intersection of Trenton and Main, Heavenly Pizza Findlay stands as a beacon for those craving authentic, locally-made food. From the famous AJ's Supreme to the innovative Cauliflower Pizza, the commitment to fresh ingredients is what keeps the Findlay community coming back for more.

The Heavenly Family Tree: Biography of the Owners and Origin Story

The story of this Ohio pizza empire is rooted in a partnership formed over 40 years ago and carried forward by family dedication. The lineage is crucial to understanding the brand's enduring success and commitment to quality.

  • Original Founders (1981): The concept of "AJ's Heavenly Pizza" was initially brought to life by partners Iggy Abbulone and John Hill. They established the original location in Tiffin, Ohio, with a vision of offering superior pizza in the region.
  • The Legacy Carrier: John Hill remained a pivotal figure, ensuring the original recipes and quality standards were maintained for decades.
  • Current Findlay Owners: The Heavenly Pizza Findlay location is proudly owned and operated by Josh Elchert and his wife, Keisha Elchert. Keisha is the daughter of original co-founder John Hill, making the Findlay shop a direct continuation of the family's culinary tradition.
  • Findlay Store History: The Findlay store has been serving the area for approximately 14 years, moving to its current, convenient location at 1132 Tiffin Ave., which has helped solidify its status as a Findlay Fan Favorite.
  • Business Philosophy: The Elcherts are known for wearing their faith on their sleeve and emphasizing community and employee appreciation, a philosophy that has garnered national attention.

The Signature Menu: Must-Try Items and Specialty Pizzas

What truly elevates Heavenly Pizza above standard fare is its dedication to making everything from scratch. Customers consistently rave about the fresh ingredients, homemade sauces, and the pillow-like crust that defines their product. The menu extends far beyond typical pepperoni and cheese, offering unique creations that cater to every craving.

The Legendary Specialty Pizzas

Heavenly Pizza has cultivated a loyal following based on its unique specialty pies. These are the items that often appear in customer reviews as the "best pizza in the state".

  • AJ's Supreme: This is the classic, all-in-one favorite. It is generously topped with pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, savory sausage, sliced ham, diced onions, green peppers, and a premium blend of cheese. It's a cornerstone of the menu and a nod to the original AJ's legacy.
  • AJ's Breakfast Pizza: A truly unique offering that has become a local sensation. This savory pie combines a tasty blend of eggs, sausage, and bacon, making it a perfect meal any time of day. It is frequently highlighted in customer testimonials as "amazing".
  • Hot and Spicy Pizza: Mentioned by customers as a reason for repeat visits, this specialty pie delivers a satisfying kick for those who like a little heat.

More Than Just Pizza

While the pizza is the main attraction, the menu is rounded out by other high-quality, homemade items, ensuring there’s something for everyone at the Findlay pizza joint.

  • Cauliflower Pizza: Catering to dietary needs and preferences, the Cauliflower Pizza is a popular low-carb option that doesn't sacrifice flavor.
  • Subs and Salads: The shop also offers a variety of subs, made with dough that is often baked fresh daily, and large salads. Any sub buns that aren't used are often donated to local organizations, highlighting their community focus.
  • Apps and Sides: The menu is complete with various appetizers, including Chicken Chunks and other sides perfect for a family meal or large gathering.

The Viral Story of Generosity: Why Heavenly Pizza is a Community Hero

The true heart of Heavenly Pizza Findlay lies not just in its delicious food but in its remarkable commitment to its employees and the Hancock County community. Owner Josh Elchert made national news with a viral act of generosity that perfectly embodies the spirit of the family business.

The Employee Appreciation Day

In a move that inspired business owners across the nation, Josh Elchert announced an "Employee Appreciation Day." On this dedicated day, he gave the entire day's profits—not just a portion, but the total sales—directly back to his employees.

This gesture was a profound way to show gratitude to his hardworking staff. The event saw the store fulfill over 220 orders on that single Monday, demonstrating the overwhelming support from the Findlay, Ohio community for a business that treats its people right. This act of kindness cemented Heavenly Pizza's reputation for exceptional customer service and a genuinely friendly staff.

Commitment to Local Quality and Service

The community connection extends beyond grand gestures. The store's daily operations are built on a foundation of quality control and local sourcing. The dough is made fresh daily, and the sauces are proprietary, ensuring a consistent, high-quality product that customers can rely on. This focus on homemade quality is a direct link back to the original vision of Iggy Abbulone and John Hill.

Furthermore, Heavenly Pizza Findlay actively participates in the local ecosystem. They are known for providing delivery and carryout services, making them a convenient option for families and businesses throughout the Findlay area. The store's location at 1132 Tiffin Ave., with ample parking and easy access, makes it a reliable destination for a quick and satisfying meal.

Topical Authority and Key Entities

The success of Heavenly Pizza is a localized phenomenon built on a strong foundation of traditional recipes and modern community values. The following entities and concepts are essential to understanding the brand's place in the Ohio culinary landscape:

  • Geographic Entities: Findlay, Ohio; Tiffin, Ohio; Hancock County; Bowling Green, Ohio (franchise location); Galion, Ohio.
  • Business Entities: Heavenly Pizza Findlay; AJ's Heavenly Pizza; Heavenly Pizza Bowling Green; Romick Railway (event partner).
  • Culinary Entities: AJ's Supreme; Breakfast Pizza; Cauliflower Pizza; Homemade Sauces; Fresh Pizza Dough; Subs; Chicken Chunks.
  • People Entities: Josh Elchert (Owner); Keisha Elchert (Owner); John Hill (Co-Founder); Iggy Abbulone (Co-Founder).
  • Service Entities: Pizza Delivery; Carryout Service; Online Ordering; Employee Appreciation Day.

In a world of mass-produced food, Heavenly Pizza Findlay stands out as a genuine article. It’s a place where the history of AJ's Heavenly Pizza meets the forward-thinking generosity of the Elchert family. Whether you are a local seeking the comfort of the AJ's Supreme or a traveler looking for the best pizza in Ohio, a visit to 1132 Tiffin Ave. promises a truly "heavenly" experience.

7 Heavenly Secrets Behind AJ's Heavenly Pizza Findlay Ohio's Unstoppable Success in 2025
ajs heavenly pizza findlay ohio
ajs heavenly pizza findlay ohio

Detail Author:

  • Name : Miss Linda Emard PhD
  • Username : jordyn42
  • Email : hodkiewicz.lurline@gmail.com
  • Birthdate : 1997-11-25
  • Address : 444 Carter Union Dibbertbury, ME 82339-0233
  • Phone : 1-571-969-6304
  • Company : Collins PLC
  • Job : Middle School Teacher
  • Bio : Est nemo velit sapiente vitae quo. Aspernatur accusamus ipsam hic mollitia. Quia rerum esse voluptatem eius ut impedit nobis aspernatur. Unde et similique occaecati accusamus et eligendi iure iste.

Socials

facebook:

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/kilback1983
  • username : kilback1983
  • bio : Et voluptatibus quos eaque itaque iure porro magni. Ipsa recusandae rerum eos debitis praesentium.
  • followers : 4450
  • following : 312

tiktok:

linkedin:

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/akilback
  • username : akilback
  • bio : Cum tempora alias culpa quis qui excepturi nobis numquam. Id assumenda optio maxime ducimus et. Veritatis ipsa eum vero rerum et voluptatibus.
  • followers : 2889
  • following : 45

Random Posts