5 Sweet Secrets: Why Capital City Cakes In Grove City, OH, Is Central Ohio's Premier Bakery
Are you searching for the definitive guide to Capital City Cakes in Grove City, OH? As of December 20, 2025, this family-owned patisserie remains the gold standard for custom and wedding cakes in the Central Ohio region, consistently earning top industry awards and rave reviews for both their artistry and their delicious, made-from-scratch recipes. It's more than just a bakery; it’s a decades-long labor of love run by the Baisden family, specializing in creating edible masterpieces that make every event sweeter.
From the charming downtown area of Grove City, this award-winning cake shop has carved out a niche as the area's premier destination for everything from elaborate tiered wedding cakes to simple, perfect Buckeyes. Whether you're planning a massive celebration or just craving a gourmet sweet treat, understanding the history, specialties, and operational details of Capital City Cakes is the first step to experiencing their celebrated quality.
The Founders and Family Legacy: Sue and Gary Baisden
Capital City Cakes is fundamentally a story of passion and family tradition, anchored by its dedicated owners, Sue and Gary Baisden. The bakery’s success is a direct result of Sue Baisden’s lifelong commitment to the craft of baking and cake decorating.
The foundation of the business was built over three decades ago, with Sue initially baking and decorating specialty cakes for family and friends. This personal, intimate approach to baking eventually blossomed into the full-scale, award-winning custom patisserie that operates today. The Baisdens’ philosophy revolves around quality ingredients, exceptional customer service, and a belief that every cake should be a unique work of art.
The family-owned and operated nature of the bakery means that every customer interaction, from the initial consultation to the final delivery, is handled with a personal touch that larger, corporate bakeries simply cannot match. This dedication is why Capital City Cakes consistently receives high praise and is often cited as a top choice for major life events, particularly weddings, throughout Grove City and the greater Columbus, Ohio, area.
Key Biography & Profile Details:
- Owners: Sue and Gary Baisden
- Expertise: Sue Baisden has over 30 years of experience in baking and decorating wedding cakes and desserts.
- Business Type: Family-owned and operated custom patisserie.
- Location: Charming downtown Grove City, Ohio.
- Reputation: Award-winning, recognized by industry leaders like The Knot and WeddingWire (Best of Weddings, BOTB Starburst logo).
Unveiling the Signature Specialties: Custom Cakes and Patisserie Menu
What truly sets Capital City Cakes apart is their mastery of custom cake design and their diverse menu of scratch-made sweet treats. They have established themselves as Central Ohio's premier cake shop by specializing in intricate, high-quality creations for any occasion.
The bakery is famous for its ability to produce a wide range of custom cakes. Their expertise covers various styles and techniques, ensuring they can bring any vision to life.
The Custom Cake Portfolio (Entities):
- Wedding Cakes: Their primary specialty, often praised for both beautiful buttercream designs and incredible taste.
- Celebration Cakes: Artistically designed cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and baby showers.
- Design Styles: They expertly handle Buttercream, Fondant, Tiered, Stacked, and Sculpted cakes, along with custom toppers.
Beyond the magnificent custom creations, the bakery offers a daily menu of smaller, irresistible baked goods, perfect for a quick indulgence or a cohesive dessert table.
The Daily Bakery Menu (Entities):
- Cupcakes: Available at $3 each or $36 per dozen.
- Buckeyes: The classic peanut butter and chocolate confection, priced at $2.00 each.
- Brownies: Rich and decadent, available for $5 each.
- Cake Pops: Fun, bite-sized treats, also $5 each.
- Cookies: Including their popular Cut-out Iced Custom Cookies, starting at $2.99 and up.
- Cookie Cakes: A great alternative to traditional sheet cakes.
This comprehensive offering, from grand, multi-tiered wedding cakes to simple, perfect Buckeyes, demonstrates their commitment to being a full-service, high-quality sweet shop for the entire community.
Planning Your Order: Location, Hours, and Contact Information
For those looking to commission a custom cake or simply stop in for a treat, knowing the current operational details is crucial. Capital City Cakes operates out of a dedicated location in Grove City, OH, and maintains specific hours to balance custom orders with their high volume of production.
Current Operational Details (As of 2025):
- Current Address: 4850 Snowy Creek Dr., Grove City, OH 43123
- Phone Number: (614) 27-SWEET (277-9338)
- Ordering Methods: Customers can order in two primary ways: via the CONTACT tab on their official website (submitting a form) or by calling the bakery directly.
The bakery’s hours reflect their focus on custom orders, particularly wedding and event cakes, which require significant time for consultations, baking, and decorating.
Capital City Cakes Store Hours:
- Monday – Thursday: 9:00 am – 5:00 pm
- Friday & Saturday: Dedicated to baking and fulfilling confirmed orders (often closed for general walk-ins).
- Sunday: CLOSED for worship and family.
It is always recommended to call ahead or submit an inquiry form for custom orders, especially for larger events like weddings, to ensure availability and to schedule a consultation. Their focus on quality means their schedule can fill up quickly, especially during peak wedding seasons.
The Customer Experience: Rave Reviews and Industry Recognition
The true measure of a bakery’s success lies in the feedback from its customers, and Capital City Cakes consistently receives glowing testimonials. Their commitment to excellence has earned them the status of an "award-winning custom patisserie" in Central Ohio.
Customers frequently highlight two key areas: the deliciousness of the product and the professionalism of the service. Reviews often praise the perfect taste of their cakes and the beauty of the final designs, particularly the flawless execution of their signature buttercream.
Top Customer Praise Points (Entities):
- Exceptional Customer Service: Described as fast, professional, and kind, ensuring a stress-free experience for wedding planning.
- Quality and Taste: The cakes are repeatedly called "delicious" and "perfect," with guests often raving about where the cake came from.
- Design Expertise: Commended for beautifully executed designs, from simple elegance to complex sculpting.
- Reliable Delivery: Cakes are delivered to venues without issue, providing peace of mind to clients.
This combination of technical skill in baking and decorating, coupled with a warm, family-style approach to client relations, solidifies Capital City Cakes' reputation as a trusted vendor. They have received multiple "Best Of" awards from major wedding planning platforms, proving their sustained quality over many years.
Why Capital City Cakes is a Must-Visit Grove City Destination
Capital City Cakes is more than just a place to buy a dessert; it’s a staple of the Grove City community and a prime example of Central Ohio entrepreneurial success. The Baisden family has successfully merged decades of baking experience with modern artistic design, making them a regional powerhouse in the custom cake world.
From the first consultation for a tiered wedding cake to grabbing a quick brownie or a handful of Buckeyes, the quality is consistently high. If you are in the Grove City or Columbus area and require a specialty cake for any occasion, or if you simply want to taste the difference that passion and experience make, Capital City Cakes should be your first call. Their dedication to making every event "sweeter" is evident in every delicious bite.
Detail Author:
- Name : Khalid Roberts
- Username : kunde.devin
- Email : marquardt.stanton@gmail.com
- Birthdate : 1995-06-04
- Address : 2165 Schneider Row West Sidhaven, KS 36086-5044
- Phone : +1-503-239-6078
- Company : Ritchie, Green and Smith
- Job : Financial Manager
- Bio : Voluptatibus voluptatem excepturi adipisci provident adipisci at. Eos nobis quis est in laudantium. Esse et laborum est itaque eligendi aut est. Et praesentium quasi quaerat.
Socials
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/samir3315
- username : samir3315
- bio : Distinctio et rerum illo expedita asperiores sint. Error consequatur non doloribus laboriosam facilis. Necessitatibus similique natus velit cum.
- followers : 2185
- following : 2945
linkedin:
- url : https://linkedin.com/in/samirquigley
- username : samirquigley
- bio : Optio reprehenderit sequi quia ducimus.
- followers : 3392
- following : 2379
